Labour Day Rally 2024 at Hong Lim Park. Photograph courtesy of Nicholas Yeo
On solidarity: a review of a dinner party
So many causes, so many activists, so many challenges. And, looming over them, always, the ominous shadow of a seemingly omnipresent and omnipotent state. Can solidarity exist in Singapore?
“I believe that all organizing is science fiction—that we are shaping the future we long for and have not yet experienced.” —adrienne maree brown Pleasure Activism: The Politics of Feeling Good
As a contributing author to the anthology We Are Not The Enemy: The Practice of Advocacy in Singapore, edited by Constance Singam and Margaret Thomas—Connie and Margie—I was invited to a celebratory dinner party at Connie’s house. The publishers, academics, environmentalists, a lawyer, a social worker, an ex-politician, an abolitionist, and a queer rights activist showed up to eat mutton samosas and chicken dum biryani.
The conversations that night left me thinking a lot about solidarity in Singapore, specifically in Singapore’s civil society. Solidarity is hard here. We are told, often and in multiple ways, that the individual, the discrete, is more important than the whole, than the inter and the intra. Meritocracy, a pillar of the Singapore identity, teaches us that only the smartest and hardest working can succeed. As Mysara Aljaru and I have previously argued in Brown is Redacted, the anthology we co-edited alongside Myle Yan Tay, there are “certain narratives, structures and policies that are actively reproduced to maintain a specific idea of a ‘multiracial society’: a society where tolerance and conscientious management are prioritised over inclusion, and where decision-making is based on majoritarianism, instead of true equity.” Some social issues are framed as more “bread-and-butter” than others, hierarchising injustices and pitting them against each other. We constantly drink the Kool-Aid of individualism: so long as we all keep to ourselves, we can all lead generally satisfactory lives. As a result, solidarity, a concept premised upon mutuality, is not intuitive to the general Singaporean, activists included. This limits our ability to push for systemic change. And it also limits our ability to forge community.
For subscribers only
Subscribe now to read this post and also gain access to Jom’s full library of content.
Overseas Singaporean voters discuss the diaspora’s role in deepening democracy,
and why they’re determined to cast their ballots in the upcoming general election.